Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant's customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive a commission from purchases made through links on our site, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Mystery Categories
Best Choice Audible 
The Blackout Murders: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 1) Audible The Blackout Murders: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 1) 
$50 Electronics Mystery Box Set Best Value Audible 
Sydney Rye Mystery Box Set, Books 1-3 
$30 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're into building, programming, or just exploring, this mystery box is a delightful surprise for anyone interAudible Sydney Rye Mystery Box Set, Books 1-3 Bookouture 
The Secret Detective Agency: A totally gripping historical English cozy murder mystery $100 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're a fan of intricate builds or seeking a blend of functionality and style, this set promises a selection ofBritt Lizz Publishing Death by Flapper: A 1920s Locked Door Murder Mystery (Heist Society Investigates Book 1) $200 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're looking to expand your own collection or searching for that perfect gift, this mystery box promises a delJoffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE CORNISH COZY MYSTERIES seven charming and addictive cozy crimes Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE CORNISH COZY MYSTERIES seven charming and addictive cozy crimes Surprise Mystery AFL Box- 8 Sealed AFL Footy Packs and a Guaranteed Hit in Box. It's a family affair here and we love trading cards and footy (Go Eagles) and we hope you love this mystery box and it bWet Dog Press Magically Murdered: A Culinary Witch Cozy Mystery with Slow-Burn Romance (Paranormal Bed & Breakfast Mysteries Book 1) $25 Electronics Mystery Box Set 5Grab yourself a $25 Mystery Box Set filled with an assortment of lucky dip products, perfect for those who love a surprWet Dog Press Magically Murdered: A Culinary Witch Cozy Mystery with Slow-Burn Romance (Paranormal Bed & Breakfast Mysteries Book 1) Pokemon Mystery Slab + 2 Booster Packs Every mystery slab is professionally graded and sealed — you won’t know what you’ve got until you open it… will it be aAMMFA Publishing The Clockmaker's Secret: a thrilling British mystery with twists up to the last page (The Slim Hardy Mysteries Book 2) EPIC POKEMON MYSTERY VALUE PACKS No gimmicks just good value and variety. I try to keep themfair and worth it.A Crumb Too Far: A Seabrook Harbor Cozy Mystery (Cozy Mysteries) Rare Glitter Dumpling Squi-shy Toy Mystery Box Bao Bun Stress Relief Toy LR Product Description1. Vibrant Steamed Bun Shape: This adorable squeezing toy is available in five bright colors: green,A Crumb Too Far: A Seabrook Harbor Cozy Mystery (Cozy Mysteries) ⭐ Pokemon Mystery Slab + 5 Booster Packs ⭐ Every mystery slab is professionally graded and sealed — you won’t know what you’ve got until you open it… will it be aMolly Black Come Get Me (A Caitlin Dare Mystery Book 1) Moonlit Glow Mystery Sparkling White -12x750ml RRP $204 F/S This sparkling white unveils a delicate balance of crisp acidity and subtle fruit notes. Its lively effervescence makesTowering Pines Publishing Trouble with Tarot: A Fiona Shaw Mystic Haven Tea Shop Mystery (Mystic Haven Tea Shop Mysteries Book 1) $100 | Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're into building, programming, or just exploring, this mystery box is a delightful surprise for anyone interTowering Pines Publishing Trouble with Tarot: A Fiona Shaw Mystic Haven Tea Shop Mystery (Mystic Haven Tea Shop Mysteries Book 1) Electronic & accessories mystery box set It’s a Mystery! You won’t know what you’re getting until you open it 🎁. Who knows what treasures you’ll find?. ComputerJoffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE HOUSE OF MYSTERY an addictive crime thriller full of twists (Ellie McEwan Book 3) $50 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE HOUSE OF MYSTERY an addictive crime thriller full of twists (Ellie McEwan Book 3) *MYSTERY* Pokemon 151 Zapdos Ex 202/165 Chase your grails with our limited-edition mystery envelopes! Mystery Hit Envelope: 151. Good luck with your pulls! • RaMurder at the Seed Swap: A Thistle & Teacake Mysteries Cozy Mystery (The Thistle & Teacake Mysteries Book 1) Murder at the Seed Swap: A Thistle & Teacake Mysteries Cozy Mystery (The Thistle & Teacake Mysteries Book 1) Saltwind Books Soap & Sabotage (Cross Bay Key Mysteries Book 1) Saltwind Books Soap & Sabotage (Cross Bay Key Mysteries Book 1) Grapevine (06th October, 2025) The Seven Dials Mystery Murder in The Villas: A Susie Jones Cozy Mystery Murder in The Villas: A Susie Jones Cozy Mystery Scene Of The Crime Publications Deadly Sanctuary: An addictive mystery crime thriller with gripping suspense (Cassidy Knox Book 1) Quince & Questions: A Honeycluck Soapstead Cozy Mystery (A Honeycluck Soapstead Mystery Book 1) Quince & Questions: A Honeycluck Soapstead Cozy Mystery (A Honeycluck Soapstead Mystery Book 1) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense FIRE ON THE NORFOLK BROADS a gripping British crime mystery (Detective Geldard Mysteries Book 3) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense FIRE ON THE NORFOLK BROADS a gripping British crime mystery (Detective Geldard Mysteries Book 3) Sunseri Design Publishing Smoked Secrets: Burnt Ends Mystery (Burnt End Mystery Book 1) A Death Before Closing Time: A Bramblewood Mystery A Death Before Closing Time: A Bramblewood Mystery Rylie Dark Girl Without a Chance (A Tara Strong Mystery Book 1) The Tea Shop Witch: A Paranormal Cozy Mystery Series with an Amateur Sleuth (The Tea Shop Witch Cozy Mysteries Book 1) The Last Owners (Crocus Hill Inn Mysteries Book 1) Bookouture A Body on the Doorstep: A completely gripping historical cozy murder mystery (London Ladies' Murder Club Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Missing Book: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Missing Book: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 1) Bookouture Don't Let Her Go: An absolutely unputdownable, heart-pounding and twisty mystery and suspense thriller (Detective Billie Beds, Breakfasts, & Beta Blockers (Three Dog Mysteries Book 1) Soon Gone (A Gemma Forge FBI Suspense Thriller—Book One) Moose Island Books Southern Spirits: A Paranormal Cozy Mystery Romance (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries Book 1) Blake Pierce: FBI Mystery Bundle (Left to Die and Girl, Alone) Blake Pierce: FBI Mystery Bundle (Left to Die and Girl, Alone) Blake Pierce When You're Mine (A Finn Wright Mystery Book 1) Elizabeth Spann Craig Checked Out (The Village Library Mysteries Book 1) The Frosted Window Murder: A Small-Town Cozy Mystery with a Yarn Shop, Tea Room, Winter Festival, Slow-Burn Romance, and The Frosted Window Murder: A Small-Town Cozy Mystery with a Yarn Shop, Tea Room, Winter Festival, Slow-Burn Romance, and If She Knew (A Kate Wise Mystery—Book 1) Fiona Grace Aged for Murder (A Tuscan Vineyard Cozy Mystery Book 1) Frosted Secrets cozy mystery : Talking cat mystery (Whiskers & Lattes Mysteries Book 1) Frosted Secrets cozy mystery : Talking cat mystery (Whiskers & Lattes Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Complete Detective Lola Harris Mysteries: six gripping Scottish crime thrillers Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Complete Detective Lola Harris Mysteries: six gripping Scottish crime thrillers A Latte to Die For: Cat Cozy Mysteries small-town (Whiskers & Lattes Mysteries Book 3) A Latte to Die For: Cat Cozy Mysteries small-town (Whiskers & Lattes Mysteries Book 3) Death in Vintage Ink: A Bellacosta Cozy Mystery (Cozy Mysteries) Death in Vintage Ink: A Bellacosta Cozy Mystery (Cozy Mysteries) Blake Pierce: Mystery Bundle (Before He Kills, Cause to Kill, Once Gone, A Trace of Death, Watching and Next Door) Sunseri Design Publishing Appetizers and Alibis: Culinary Cozy Mystery (Alphabet Soup Mysteries Series Book 1) Ringtail Press Pawsitively Poisonous: A Cozy Witch Mystery (A Witch of Edgehill Mystery Book 1) Westward Publishing / Carly Fall, LLC Herbs and Homicide: A Small Town Contemporary Cozy Mystery (Heywood Herbalist Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Espresso Overboard: cat Cozy mystery (Whiskers & Lattes Mysteries Book 6) Espresso Overboard: cat Cozy mystery (Whiskers & Lattes Mysteries Book 6) Ancient Chapters The Mystery of the Blue Train: A Gripping Hercule Poirot Mystery of Murder, Secrets, and Luxury Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Seaside Treasure: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 7) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Seaside Treasure: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 7) Write from the Heart Publications Who Am I Spooking With? (A Spot-On Cozy Mystery Book 1) Vinci Books Nothing New Under the Sun: An Archaeological Thriller Where Ancient Secrets and Deadly Conspiracies Collide (A Carter De Vinci Books Nothing New Under the Sun: An Archaeological Thriller Where Ancient Secrets and Deadly Conspiracies Collide (A Carter De Fiona Grace Thistlewood Manor: Murder at the Hedgerow (An Eliza Montagu Cozy Mystery Book 1) Bookouture Itsy Bitsy Spider: An unputdownable and gripping crime thriller (Emma Frost Book 1) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense MURDER IN GALLOWAY an absolutely gripping and atmospheric Scottish crime mystery (Detective Marjory Fleming Mysteries Bo Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense MURDER IN GALLOWAY an absolutely gripping and atmospheric Scottish crime mystery (Detective Marjory Fleming Mysteries Bo Independently published 100 Color by Number Mysteries: A Coloring Book for Adults Relaxation and Wonder – Squares, Diamonds, Dots Bookouture Death by Candlelight: A totally gripping cozy murder mystery (The Adam and Eve Mystery Series Book 1) Silver Quill Publishing Dirty Little Secrets (J.J. Graves Mysteries Book 1) Bookouture The Next Girl: A gripping crime thriller with a heart-stopping twist (Detective Gina Harte Book 1) Best Cosy Books True Confections: Cozy Mystery (Cupcake Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Katie Rush Dark Corners (A Dana Blaze Mystery Book 1) Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Tule Publishing A Long Shadow: British Detective Series (Chief Inspector Shadow Mystery Book 1) Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense MURDER IN KNOCKHAVEN HARBOUR an absolutely gripping and atmospheric Scottish crime mystery (Detective Marjory Fleming My Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense MURDER IN KNOCKHAVEN HARBOUR an absolutely gripping and atmospheric Scottish crime mystery (Detective Marjory Fleming My Next Chapter Murder on Tyneside (Agnes Lockwood Mysteries Book 1) Beaverstone Press Dial P For Poison (Movie Club Mysteries, Book 1): An Irish Cozy Mystery Murder in the Manor (A Lacey Doyle Cozy Mystery—Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense A Bookish Twist: a gripping English cozy mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 6) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense A Bookish Twist: a gripping English cozy mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 6) Audible Cozy Witch Mysteries: Special Edition Box Set of 8 Books: Angela Pepper Box Sets and Bundles Audible Cozy Witch Mysteries: Special Edition Box Set of 8 Books: Angela Pepper Box Sets and Bundles Anna de Wahl, Self-Published The Mysterious Guest: Cedar Harbor Cozy Mysteries A Precarious Homecoming: An Arabella Stewart Historical Mystery (Arabella Stewart Historical Mysteries Book 1) Westward Publishing / Carly Fall, LLC The Guest is a Goner: A Humorous Paranormal Cozy Mystery (Sedona Spirit Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense A Bookish Disappearance: a gripping English cozy mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 7) Sunwalker Press The Corpse in the Cabana (Viola Roberts Cozy Mystery Book 1)